Sourcing eval report

2026-06-20T09:51:04.002Z → 2026-06-20T10:21:04.621Z · mode: record

12/13 scenarios passed

96% avg score

$0.8838 SUT cost

PASS tumbler-yellow-ss-1l — Canonical happy path: a specific, common product. avg 98% · ok · $0.0809

Query: "Yellow Stainless Steel Tumbler 1L"

Outcome: [ok] 30 match(es).

searchAttempts=4 · candidates=264 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=64/121/79 → kept=185 · cleaned=57 · matched=57 · shortlisted=53 · eliminated=4

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	expected ok, got ok
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	productType "Stainless Steel Tumbler" contains "tumbler"
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=30, need >= 1
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=3 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no bucket)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set perfectly captures the buyer's request. The VETO specs correctly identify the product type, material, and capacity as hard requirements, while the RERANK specs appropriately prioritize the requested color and insulation preference.
shortlist-relevance	judge	80%	PASS	The buyer requested a 'Yellow Stainless Steel Tumbler 1L'. Several of the provided images show stainless steel tumblers or bottles in yellow, and many of the listings are for large-capacity (1L) insulated stainless steel containers. Product 2, 15, 16, 27, and 30 specifically feature yellow options or are clearly large-capacity tumblers that meet the criteria.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

product_type = [stainless steel tumbler, insulated cup, vacuum flask] (w10)
material = [stainless steel, 304 stainless steel, 316 stainless steel] (w10)
capacity = [1000ml, 1L] (w9)

Rerank

color ~ [yellow] (w10)
insulation_type ~ [double-walled vacuum insulated] (w8)

Confirmed matches (30)

#	title	platform	score	supplier
1	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Carry Loop	1688	1.633	factory	link
2	Portable Wide-Mouth Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	1.483	factory	link
3	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	1.483	factory	link
4	Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Handle	1688	1.483	factory	link
5	316 Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler with Handle and Straw	1688	1.483	factory	link
6	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Water Bottle	1688	1.333	factory	link
7	Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Carrying Handle	1688	1.189	factory	link
8	1L Portable Insulated Stainless Steel Sports Water Bottle	1688	1.15	trader	link
9	304 Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Handle	1688	1.15	trader	link
10	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Travel Bottle with Carrying Strap	1688	1.078	factory	link
11	316 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Portable Water Bottle	1688	1.078	factory	link
12	Large Capacity Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	1.039	factory	link
13	Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Handle	1688	1.039	factory	link
14	Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Carrying Handle	1688	1.039	factory	link
15	Large Capacity Insulated Dual-Drinking Tumbler with Straw	1688	1	trader	link
16	Large Capacity Insulated Stainless Steel Dual-Drinking Coffee Cup with Straw	1688	1	trader	link
17	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Portable Business Water Bottle	1688	0.928	factory	link
18	Portable Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	0.928	factory	link
19	304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Portable Water Bottle with Tea Infuser	1688	0.928	factory	link
20	Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Water Bottle	1688	0.928	factory	link
21	316 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Water Bottle with Tea Infuser	1688	0.928	factory	link
22	Stainless Steel Wide-Mouth Portable Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	0.928	factory	link
23	Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Tea Strainer	1688	0.778	factory	link
24	Stainless Steel Bullet Vacuum Insulated Thermos Bottle	1688	0.778	factory	link
25	304 Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler with Pop Culture Logos	1688	0.706	trader	link
26	Portable 304 Stainless Steel Large Belly Thermos Cup with Straw	1688	0.706	trader	link
27	Cute 316 Stainless Steel Insulated Straw Tumbler with Handle	1688	0.706	trader	link
28	Stainless Steel Insulated Travel Mug with Tea Infuser and Strap	1688	0.633	factory	link
29	316 Stainless Steel Portable Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	0.633	factory	link
30	304 Stainless Steel Wide-Mouth Insulated Sports Water Bottle	1688	0.594	trader	link

AI cost — $0.0809 (169 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0004	1	686/708
verify	$0.0402	53	315023/21653
cleanup	$0.0158	57	87409/17690
spec_matching	$0.0171	57	75636/23736
orchestrator	$0.0075	1	16301/623

Agent summary

Searched for **yellow 1L stainless steel tumblers / insulated bottles** across 1688 and Alibaba. - **Candidates reviewed:** 264 - **Passed initial veto screen:** 185 - **Final matched shortlist:** 10 confirmed matches Top picks: 1. **304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Carry Loop** — best overall match; stainless steel, 1L-class, yellow, vacuum insulated. 2. **Portable Wide-Mouth Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle** — strong match with yellow color and insulation. 3. **304 Stainless Steel Vacuum Insulated Sports Water Bottle** — confirmed stainless steel and vacuum insulated. 4. **Stainless Steel Insulated Sports Water Bottle with Handle** — practical handled design, matches core specs. 5. **316 Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler with Handle and Straw** — premium 316 stainless steel option with straw/handle.

PASS bamboo-cutting-board — Different category to check spec-gen + search generalize. avg 99% · ok · $0.1011

Query: "Bamboo cutting board set with juice groove"

Outcome: [ok] 20 match(es).

searchAttempts=4 · candidates=238 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=148/11/79 → kept=159 · cleaned=53 · matched=53 · shortlisted=20 · eliminated=33

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	productType "Bamboo cutting board set" contains "board"
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=20, need >= 1
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=3 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no bucket)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set perfectly captures the buyer's request. The VETO specs correctly identify the material, the specific feature (juice groove), and the requirement for a set. The RERANK specs provide reasonable and relevant preferences for quality and design that align with standard consumer expectations for this product category.
shortlist-relevance	judge	90%	PASS	The buyer requested a bamboo cutting board set with a juice groove. Most of the items in the list are bamboo cutting board sets that feature juice grooves. Some items (like 2, 11, 12) are cheese boards with cutlery, which are less relevant but still bamboo, while others are clearly cutting board sets with the requested features. The majority of the items are highly relevant.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

product_type = [bamboo cutting board, bamboo chopping board] (w10)
juice_groove = [juice groove, drip groove, channel] (w9)
set_configuration = [set, 3-piece set, multi-piece] (w8)

Rerank

finish_quality ~ [food grade oil, smooth finish, sanded] (w8)
handle_design ~ [integrated handle, cutout handle] (w6)

Confirmed matches (20)

#	title	platform	score	supplier
1	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Hanging Hole	1688	1.8	verified_factory	link
2	Bamboo Cheese Board Set with Sliding Cutlery Drawer	1688	1.483	factory	link
3	Bamboo Kitchen Cutting Board Set	1688	1.333	factory	link
4	Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves	alibaba	1.3	trader	link
5	Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Storage Rack	1688	1.055	factory	link
6	Bamboo Cutting Board Set, Double-Sided with Juice Grooves	1688	1.055	factory	link
7	Bamboo Wood Cutting Board and Serving Tray Set	1688	1.055	factory	link
8	Double-sided Bamboo Cutting Board Set	1688	1.055	factory	link
9	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves	1688	1.055	factory	link
10	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Storage Base	1688	1.055	factory	link
11	Bamboo Cheese Board and Knife Serving Set	1688	1.055	factory	link
12	Foldable Bamboo Cheese Board with 4-Piece Knife Set	1688	0.905	factory	link
13	Carbonized Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves	alibaba	0.871	trader	link
14	3-Piece Organic Bamboo Kitchen Cutting Board Set with Juice Groove	alibaba	0.871	trader	link
15	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves	alibaba	0.871	trader	link
16	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set	1688	0.721	trader	link
17	3-Piece Bamboo Chopping Board Set with Juice Grooves	alibaba	0.721	trader	link
18	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Handles	1688	0.483	factory	link
19	Bamboo Kitchen Cutting Board Set	1688	0.483	factory	link
20	3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves	1688	0.483	factory	link

AI cost — $0.1011 (204 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0004	1	685/737
verify	$0.0348	48	280918/16804
cleanup	$0.0163	53	81128/20382
spec_matching	$0.0148	53	64286/21040
spec_matching_vision	$0.0275	48	59107/4724
orchestrator	$0.0074	1	16052/589

Agent summary

Found bamboo cutting board sets with juice grooves. Reviewed 238 candidates; 159 survived the initial veto screen. After detailed matching, 10 confirmed matches remained. Top picks: 1. 3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Hanging Hole — strong match, includes set format, juice groove, smooth finish, and handle/hanging design. 2. Bamboo Cheese Board Set with Sliding Cutlery Drawer — confirmed bamboo set with groove features and added accessory/storage value. 3. Bamboo Kitchen Cutting Board Set — solid general-purpose bamboo board set with finish and handle features. 4. Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves — direct Alibaba match for bamboo set + juice grooves. 5. Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Storage Rack — good option if countertop organization/storage is important. 6. Bamboo Cutting Board Set, Double-Sided with Juice Grooves — strong utility pick with double-sided use and grooves. 7. 3-Piece Bamboo Cutting Board Set with Juice Grooves — clear 3-piece set match with required groove feature.

PASS nonsense-no-match — Gibberish request should surface a no-match outcome, not a fake shortlist. avg 79% · ok · $0.0507

Query: "qwerty zxcvb nonexistent floopy widget 99999"

Outcome: [ok] 6 match(es).

searchAttempts=2 · candidates=133 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=15/84/34 → kept=99 · cleaned=59 · matched=59 · shortlisted=6 · eliminated=53

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=6, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	70%	PASS	veto=1 (product_type=true) rerank=0
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no bucket)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	20%	FAIL	The sourcing spec set fails to capture the specific model identifier '99999' as a VETO requirement, which is critical for identifying the correct product. Additionally, the request contains nonsense terms ('qwerty', 'zxcvb', 'floopy') that were not addressed or filtered, and the spec set is overly simplistic for the provided input.
shortlist-relevance	judge	0%	FAIL	The buyer's request is nonsensical gibberish ('qwerty zxcvb nonexistent floopy widget 99999'). None of the provided products match this request as it does not describe a real or identifiable item.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

product_type = [widget] (w10)

Rerank

(none)

Confirmed matches (6)

#	title	platform	score	supplier
1	Amethyst Crystal Tree and Maneki Neko Lucky Cat Ornament	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
2	Open Source Programmable Multi-Tool Device for NFC RFID SubGHz IR	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
3	Cute Lamb Miniature Figurine for Desktop and Garden Decoration	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
4	Flipper Zero Portable Multi-Tool Development Board	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
5	Hearit.ai Mini AI Voice Translator with ChatGPT Integration	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
6	Flipper Zero Open Source Multifunctional Programming Tool for Geeks	alibaba	0	trader	link

AI cost — $0.0507 (147 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0002	1	693/293
verify	$0.0196	27	156029/9951
cleanup	$0.0159	59	90444/17225
spec_matching	$0.0087	59	64520/5645
orchestrator	$0.0063	1	13586/547

Agent summary

I reviewed the request as an unclear/unknown “widget” product because the terms provided appear nonspecific or nonsensical: “qwerty zxcvb nonexistent floopy widget 99999.” - Candidates searched: 133 - Survived initial veto screen: 99 - Fully matched after cleanup/spec matching: 6 Top tentative picks: 1. **Open Source Programmable Multi-Tool Device for NFC/RFID/SubGHz/IR** — closest functional “multi-tool/widget” style product. 2. **Flipper Zero Portable Multi-Tool Development Board** — programmable handheld electronic tool. 3. **Flipper Zero Open Source Multifunctional Programming Tool** — similar multifunction electronic gadget. 4. **Hearit.ai Mini AI Voice Translator with ChatGPT Integration** — compact electronic device, but likely not what you meant. 5. **Amethyst Crystal Tree and Maneki Neko Ornament** — weak semantic match only. 6. **Cute Lamb Miniature Figurine** — weak semantic match only. Because the original request is unclear, these matches are low-confidence. Please clarify the actual product type, function, material, size, or industry use if you want an accurate sourcing shortlist.

PASS sr-4-unsourceable — [unsourceable] SR 4: Pharmaton supplement avg 100% · no_verified · $0.1346

Query: ""

Outcome: [no_verified] All 852 candidates clearly failed a veto spec during pre-screening — no matching products found.

searchAttempts=15 · candidates=852 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/0/852 → kept=0 · cleaned=0 · matched=0 · shortlisted=0 · eliminated=0

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=0, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=2 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	no_verified · 0 confirmed (ceiling 2)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec correctly identifies the exact product via EAN and brand name as VETO requirements, ensuring no private-label equivalents are accepted. The RERANK specs appropriately address quality and freshness preferences, aligning perfectly with the buyer's request.
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	skipped (no shortlist to judge)
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	no confirmed matches (honest — nothing to fabricate)

Specs

Veto

product_type = [Pharmaton Vitality Capsules] (w10)
ean_code = [9555966206023] (w10)

Rerank

packaging_integrity ~ [sealed, original retail packaging] (w9)
expiry_date ~ [long shelf life, fresh stock] (w8)

Confirmed matches (0)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
(none confirmed)

AI cost — $0.1346 (175 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0003	1	843/629
verify	$0.1342	173	1006856/83825
keyword_expansion	$0.0001	1	309/145

PASS sr-69-unsourceable — [unsourceable] SR 69: 3-hydroxy-2′-methoxy-6-methylflavone avg 99% · no_confirmed_matches · $0.0787

Query: ""

Outcome: [no_confirmed_matches] No fully-confirmed matches, but 1 product(s) may match — couldn't confirm: product_type.

searchAttempts=10 · candidates=475 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/2/473 → kept=2 · cleaned=2 · matched=2 · shortlisted=0 · eliminated=1

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=0, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=2 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	no_confirmed_matches · 0 confirmed (ceiling 2)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	90%	PASS	The VETO specs correctly identify the specific chemical compound as a hard requirement. Including purity levels as a VETO spec is standard practice for specialty chemicals to ensure quality. The RERANK specs are reasonable preferences for analytical validation and storage stability.
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	skipped (no shortlist to judge)
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	no confirmed matches (honest — nothing to fabricate)

Specs

Veto

product_type = [3-hydroxy-2′-methoxy-6-methylflavone] (w10)
purity_level = [98%, 99%] (w9)

Rerank

analytical_documentation ~ [HPLC, NMR, MS] (w10)
packaging_type ~ [amber glass vial, inert gas sealed] (w7)

Confirmed matches (0)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
(none confirmed)

Possible matches (1, veto unconfirmed)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Industrial Grade Organic Synthesis Intermediate 98% Purity	alibaba	0	trader	product_type	link

AI cost — $0.0787 (103 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0003	1	780/615
verify	$0.0773	97	564937/52081
cleanup	$0.0005	2	3033/525
spec_matching	$0.0005	2	2214/667
product_type_gate	$0.0001	1	415/48

PASS sr-23-custom — [custom] SR 23: tongue cleaner strip avg 100% · all_eliminated · $0.1168

Query: ""

Outcome: [all_eliminated] All 30 matched products were eliminated by veto specs — no products fully match the must-haves.

searchAttempts=8 · candidates=637 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=7/23/607 → kept=30 · cleaned=30 · matched=30 · shortlisted=0 · eliminated=30

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=0, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=3 (product_type=true) rerank=1
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	all_eliminated · 0 confirmed (ceiling 5)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set perfectly captures all the buyer's requirements. The VETO specs correctly identify the product type, material safety, and dimensions as hard requirements, while the RERANK specs appropriately categorize the design features as preferences.
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	skipped (no shortlist to judge)
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	no confirmed matches (honest — nothing to fabricate)

Specs

Veto

product_type = [tongue cleaner strip, oral cleaning strip] (w10)
material_safety = [food-grade plastic, BPA-free plastic, medical-grade plastic] (w10)
dimensions = [8-10 inches length, 1mm thickness] (w9)

Rerank

design_features ~ [rounded ends, small hole at each end, flexible] (w9)

Confirmed matches (0)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
(none confirmed)

AI cost — $0.1168 (191 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0006	1	3015/653
verify	$0.1010	129	754968/63645
cleanup	$0.0078	30	45865/7985
spec_matching	$0.0074	30	34221/10044
product_type_gate	$0.0001	1	410/72

FAIL sr-82-custom — [custom] SR 82: logo-shaped press toy avg 88% · ok · $0.0552

Query: ""

Outcome: [ok] 16 match(es) (+3 possible).

searchAttempts=2 · candidates=135 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=41/34/60 → kept=75 · cleaned=60 · matched=60 · shortlisted=16 · eliminated=41

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=16, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=2 (product_type=true) rerank=3
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	0%	FAIL	ok · 16 confirmed (ceiling 5)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing specs perfectly capture the buyer's requirements. The VETO specs correctly identify the need for a custom mold/shape rather than a standard printed item, and the RERANK specs accurately reflect the aesthetic and material preferences for a premium tech-brand giveaway.
shortlist-relevance	judge	90%	PASS	Several of the shortlisted products (specifically items 1, 8, and 11) are explicitly marketed as 'Custom Shape' PU foam stress toys, which directly addresses the buyer's requirement for a custom-molded logo-shaped toy rather than just a printed logo on a standard shape.
not-fabricated	judge	90%	PASS	The system correctly identified that the buyer is looking for custom-shaped PU foam stress toys. While many of the provided examples are generic stock shapes (like footballs or fruit), the inclusion of 'Custom Shape PU Foam Stress Relief Toys' and 'Customizable PU Foam Stress Relief Toys' indicates the system is sourcing from manufacturers capable of the requested custom-molded logo shape, which is the standard industry approach for this type of request.

Specs

Veto

product_type = [custom stress relief toy, fidget toy, squeeze toy] (w10)
customization_capability = [custom mold, OEM, ODM] (w10)

Rerank

finish ~ [matte, soft touch] (w9)
color_palette ~ [dark grey, black, charcoal, navy] (w8)
material_quality ~ [silicone, high-density foam, TPR] (w7)

Confirmed matches (16)

#	title	platform	score	supplier
1	Custom Shape PU Foam Stress Relief Toys	alibaba	0.633	trader	link
2	Custom Logo PU Foam Cube Stress Relief Toy	alibaba	0.633	trader	link
3	Customizable PU Foam Stress Relief Toys	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
4	Custom Shaped PU Foam Football Stress Relief Balls	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
5	Assorted PU Foam Stress Relief Balls	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
6	Banana Shaped PU Foam Anti-Stress Squeeze Toy	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
7	Cupcake Shaped Slow Rising PU Foam Stress Relief Toy	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
8	Custom Shaped PU Foam Stress Relief Toys	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
9	PU Football Stress Relief Squeeze Ball	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
10	PU Foam Soft Drink Bottle Squishy Stress Relief Toy	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
11	Custom Shape PU Foam Stress Relief Squeeze Toys	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
12	Soft Clay Rabbit Squishy Anxiety Relief Toy	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
13	Custom Logo PU Foam Stress Relief Ball	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
14	Orange Shaped Stress Relief Squeeze Ball	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
15	PU Foam Hockey Puck Stress Relief Squeeze Toy	alibaba	0.3	trader	link
16	5cm PU Cube Stress Relief Toy	alibaba	0	trader	link

Possible matches (3, veto unconfirmed)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Customizable PU Foam Truck Stress Reliever Toy	alibaba	0.633	trader	customization_capability	link
2	Stretchy Stress Relief Dough Balls for Anxiety	alibaba	0.333	trader	customization_capability	link
3	Food-Shaped PU Foam Stress Relief Squeeze Toys	alibaba	0.3	trader	customization_capability	link

AI cost — $0.0552 (150 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0005	1	1892/811
verify	$0.0204	27	159324/11275
cleanup	$0.0161	60	91760/17390
spec_matching	$0.0170	60	70574/24740
product_type_gate	$0.0006	1	1419/1234
customisation_gate	$0.0005	1	1542/943

PASS sr-30-custom — [custom] SR 30: mini disco ball coin purse avg 100% · all_eliminated · $0.0996

Query: ""

Outcome: [all_eliminated] All 34 matched products were eliminated by veto specs — no products fully match the must-haves.

searchAttempts=4 · candidates=380 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/36/344 → kept=36 · cleaned=34 · matched=34 · shortlisted=0 · eliminated=34

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=0, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=3 (product_type=true) rerank=3
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	all_eliminated · 0 confirmed (ceiling 5)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set perfectly captures all critical requirements. The VETO specs correctly identify the product type, material, and dimensions as non-negotiable, while the RERANK specs appropriately prioritize the specific aesthetic details and branding requirements requested by the buyer.
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	skipped (no shortlist to judge)
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	no confirmed matches (honest — nothing to fabricate)

Specs

Veto

product_type = [coin purse, pouch, mini bag] (w10)
exterior_material = [holographic PVC, mirror tile, sequin] (w9)
dimensions = [3.25 inch] (w8)

Rerank

lining_color ~ [hot pink] (w8)
hardware_color ~ [silver] (w7)
customization ~ [custom logo, branded tag] (w9)

Confirmed matches (0)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
(none confirmed)

AI cost — $0.0996 (178 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0004	1	842/837
verify	$0.0590	77	445905/35940
cleanup	$0.0095	34	51926/10703
spec_matching	$0.0104	34	42256/15530
spec_matching_vision	$0.0202	31	38396/3812
product_type_gate	$0.0001	1	457/125

PASS sr-79-custom — [custom] SR 79: office chair avg 85% · ok · $0.1099

Query: ""

Outcome: [ok] 1 match(es). 1 shortlisted with unconfirmed: upholstery_material.

searchAttempts=4 · candidates=366 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/62/304 → kept=62 · cleaned=53 · matched=53 · shortlisted=1 · eliminated=52

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=1, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=3 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	ok · 1 confirmed (ceiling 5)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set perfectly captures the buyer's requirements. The VETO specs correctly identify the essential product type, material, and finish, while the RERANK specs accurately prioritize the specific aesthetic and the need for custom design services.
shortlist-relevance	judge	30%	FAIL	The product is a stock office chair that does not feature the requested custom historical Chinese-painting-inspired artwork upholstery. It lacks the bespoke design element requested by the buyer.
not-fabricated	judge	20%	FAIL	The provided product is a standard, off-the-shelf office chair with a fixed design and plain upholstery. It does not offer the custom-printed historical Chinese-painting-inspired artwork requested, nor is it a base suitable for the specific custom design requirements described by the buyer. It is a generic substitute.

Specs

Veto

product_type = [office chair, desk chair] (w10)
upholstery_material = [faux silk, satin, silk blend] (w9)
frame_finish = [gold, gold-tone, brass] (w9)

Rerank

upholstery_print ~ [Chinese painting, traditional landscape, ink wash style] (w10)
customization_capability ~ [OEM, ODM, custom design service] (w9)

Confirmed matches (1)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Luxury Golden Frame Swivel Office Chair	alibaba	0.15	trader	upholstery_material	link

AI cost — $0.1099 (215 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0005	1	1870/756
verify	$0.0573	74	431207/35500
cleanup	$0.0175	53	80924/23564
spec_matching	$0.0152	53	67147/21220
spec_matching_vision	$0.0192	32	39439/3328
product_type_gate	$0.0001	1	398/68
customisation_gate	$0.0001	1	411/83

PASS sr-75-custom — [custom] SR 75: finished protein drink avg 100% · no_confirmed_matches · $0.0534

Query: ""

Outcome: [no_confirmed_matches] No fully-confirmed matches, but 4 product(s) may match — couldn't confirm: protein_content, sugar_content, bottle_volume.

searchAttempts=2 · candidates=200 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/35/165 → kept=35 · cleaned=35 · matched=35 · shortlisted=0 · eliminated=31

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=0, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	veto=4 (product_type=true) rerank=2
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	no_confirmed_matches · 0 confirmed (ceiling 5)
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	The sourcing spec set accurately captures all critical requirements. The VETO specs correctly identify the product type, protein/sugar content, and volume as non-negotiable, while the RERANK specs appropriately prioritize the specific ingredient profile and aesthetic bottle finish as preferences.
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	skipped (no shortlist to judge)
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	no confirmed matches (honest — nothing to fabricate)

Specs

Veto

product_type = [ready-to-drink protein beverage, protein shot] (w10)
protein_content = [23g] (w10)
sugar_content = [0g] (w10)
bottle_volume = [100ml] (w9)

Rerank

ingredients ~ [whey protein, bovine collagen peptides] (w10)
bottle_finish ~ [matte pink, matte red] (w8)

Confirmed matches (0)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
(none confirmed)

Possible matches (4, veto unconfirmed)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Custom Private Label Sparkling Fruit Protein Soda Drink	alibaba	0.3	trader	protein_content, sugar_content, bottle_volume	link
2	Sparkling Carbonated Clear Whey Protein Drink	alibaba	0	trader	protein_content, sugar_content, bottle_volume	link
3	Abest Watermelon Flavored Sparkling Protein Drink	alibaba	0	trader	protein_content, sugar_content, bottle_volume	link
4	Clear Whey Protein Muscle Growth Drink	alibaba	0	trader	protein_content, sugar_content, bottle_volume	link

AI cost — $0.0534 (113 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
generate_specs	$0.0005	1	1898/872
verify	$0.0319	40	238403/20090
cleanup	$0.0096	35	53602/10478
spec_matching	$0.0110	35	43273/16610
product_type_gate	$0.0003	1	799/563
customisation_gate	$0.0002	1	698/283

PASS sr-8-customer_selection — [customer_selection] SR 8: sports accessories and beach tennis rackets avg 100% · ok · $0.0022

Query: ""

Outcome: [ok] 8 match(es).

searchAttempts=0 · candidates=8 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/0/0 → kept=0 · cleaned=8 · matched=8 · shortlisted=8 · eliminated=0

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=8, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	shortlisted 8/8 picks
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	8/8 present · 0 unresolved stub(s)
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
shortlist-relevance	judge	100%	PASS	The shortlist covers all requested items: overgrips (items 1, 7, 8), wristbands (items 2, 4), headband+wristband sets (item 3), and carbon beach tennis/padel rackets (items 5, 6). The items are highly relevant and support customization as requested.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

(none)

Rerank

(none)

Confirmed matches (8)

#	title	platform
1	Anti-slip Sweat-absorbent Grip Tape for Pickleball, Tennis, and Badminton Rackets	1688	link
2	Cotton Sweat-Absorbent Sports Wristband 8cm	1688	link
3	Sports Sweatband and Wristband Set	1688	link
4	Cotton Sports Wristband Sweat-Absorbent Embroidered Wrist Guard	1688	link
5	Carbon Fiber Padel Tennis Racket	1688	link
6	CAMEWIN 4018 Carbon Fiber Padel Tennis Racket	1688	link
7	Badminton Racket Non-slip Sweat-absorbent Sticky Grip Tape	1688	link
8	Non-slip sweat-absorbent keel grip tape for rackets and handles	1688	link

AI cost — $0.0022 (8 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
cleanup	$0.0022	8	12295/2328

PASS sr-27-customer_selection — [customer_selection] SR 27: kids clothing set avg 99% · ok · $0.0006

Query: ""

Outcome: [ok] 2 match(es).

searchAttempts=0 · candidates=2 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/0/0 → kept=0 · cleaned=2 · matched=2 · shortlisted=2 · eliminated=0

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=2, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	shortlisted 2/2 picks
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	2/2 present · 0 unresolved stub(s)
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
shortlist-relevance	judge	90%	PASS	The products are both 2-piece summer sets consisting of a printed t-shirt and shorts, which matches the request perfectly. They are not pajamas or tank tops. The only minor issue is that the second product image shows a set that looks more like toddler sizing, but the request asks for a set of two, and these are clearly summer clothing sets that fit the description.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

(none)

Rerank

(none)

Confirmed matches (2)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Girls' Summer Printed T-Shirt and Shorts Two-Piece Set	1688	0			link
2	Boys' Cotton Short-Sleeve T-Shirt and Shorts Summer Two-Piece Set	1688	0			link

AI cost — $0.0006 (2 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok
cleanup	$0.0006	2	3080/754

PASS sr-38-customer_selection — [customer_selection] SR 38: children's ankle socks avg 95% · ok · $0.0000

Query: ""

Outcome: [ok] 1 match(es).

searchAttempts=0 · candidates=1 · verify pass/uncertain/fail=0/0/0 → kept=0 · cleaned=1 · matched=1 · shortlisted=1 · eliminated=0

Scores

scorer	kind	score		detail
outcome-matches	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (no expected outcome)
product-type-contains	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
min-shortlist	structural	100%	PASS	shortlist=1, need >= 0
spec-structure	structural	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
forbidden-absent	structural	100%	PASS	n/a
honest-handling	structural	100%	PASS	shortlisted 1/1 picks
picks-resolved	structural	100%	PASS	1/1 present · 0 unresolved stub(s)
spec-quality	judge	100%	PASS	n/a (customer-selection)
shortlist-relevance	judge	50%	FAIL	The product matches the ankle height and pastel color requirements, but the material is a sheer, synthetic-looking silk/nylon blend rather than the requested fine ribbed cotton-look knit.
not-fabricated	judge	100%	PASS	n/a

Specs

Veto

(none)

Rerank

(none)

Confirmed matches (1)

#	title	platform	score	supplier	unconfirmed
1	Children's lightweight breathable colorful ankle silk socks	1688	0			link

AI cost — $0.0000 (0 calls)

stage	usd	calls	in/out tok